We also cater! Contact us for your special event.
Please be sure to indicate any allergies or dietary needs. We can also make many of our items gluten free.
Cookies
Frosted Sugar Cookie
Our most popular cookie! Various shapes available with buttercream frosting.
Biscotti
Double chocolate chip, pistachio almond, vanilla or chocolate almond, orange cranberry.
Italian Anise or Vanilla
Great with coffee or tea, these pack a lovely flavor. Available with anise or vanilla flavoring.
Chocolate Italian “Meatballs”
Traditional Italian cookie with hints of nutmeg and cinnamon.
Thumbprints
Buttery cookies filled with homemade jam!
Half Moons
Rich chocolate cake-like cookie frosted with chocolate fudge and vanilla.
Pumpkin Spice
All the flavors you love about fall, with a sweet vanilla glaze!
Checkered Chip
A classic cookie combining semi-sweet and white chocolate chips.
Rise & Shine
Our signature cookie bar made with oats, dried apricots, cranberries, and chocolate chips.
Molasses Cookies
Deliciously soft cookies with deep molasses flavor and notes of warm ginger and cinnamon.
Italian Rainbow Bars
Three-layers of raspberry and almond deliciousness coated in chocolate!
Snickerdoodles
Chewy cinnamon sugar goodness!
Cakes
All our cakes are also available as cupcakes!
Classic Vanilla
A white cake with filling of your choice and our buttercream frosting.
Strawberries & Cream
Our vanilla cake layered with vanilla pudding and strawberries, frosted with whipped topping.
Chocolate Fudge
Rich chocolate flavor with our buttercream frosting or ganache and your choice of filling.
Orange Creamsicle
A light cake with hints of orange in a whipped frosting with candied orange peels
Cannoli
All the scrumptious flavors of a cannoli baked in a cake!
Italian Rainbow Cake
Three-layers of raspberry and almond deliciousness coated in chocolate frosting, just like our cookies – but a cake!
Breads and Pastries
All our sweet breads are also available as muffins!
Pumpkin Bread
A family favorite combining fall flavors with chocolate!
Cinnamon Swirl
Delicious as is or warmed with butter!
Chocolate Bread
A rich chocolate bread made with Greek yogurt. Delicious!
Zucchini Bread
Have yours traditional style or chocolate! (Seasonal)
Summer Herb Bread
An egg and herb bread to delight
your senses!
Fudge Bomb Brownies
The best brownie you’ll ever eat! A fan favorite.
Spice or Apple Spice
All the fall flavors you love in a loaf! (Seasonal)
Focaccia
Delicious herb and garlic infused bread perfect on its own or with your favorite cheeses!
Donuts
Available in regular glazed, chocolate glazed, pumpkin, or cinnamon sugar!
Vanilla Bread Pudding
Brioche bread, cinnamon custard and sweet vanilla cream.
Blueberry Lavender Tarts
Floral notes compliment fresh blueberries in a flaky shell.
Scones
Available in strawberry, lemon blueberry, vanilla spice, orange cranberry or cherry vanilla, apple pie, spiced pear & maple pecan!
Barks, Brittles & Chocolates
Milk Chocolate Almond
Milk Chocolate Toffee
Pecan Praline (milk chocolate, pecans, caramel)
Dark Chocolate Orange
Dark Chocolate Mint
Sweet & Salty (white chocolate, peanut butter, pretzels)
White Chocolate Fruit (cranberries & blueberries)
Peanut Brittle
Cashew Brittle
Chocolate Covered Smores (milk or dark)
Nonpareils (milk or dark)
Truffles (tiramisu, Irish cream, or cherry cordial)
Chocolate candies (various shapes and flavors, filled or solid)
Fudge flavors: milk chocolate, dark chocolate, raspberry, strawberry, cheesecake, vanilla, banana, butterscotch, dark chocolate cinnamon, birthday cake, coffee, cookies & cream, maple, mint, peach, pumpkin pie, lemon, coconut, orange, red velvet, cherry, salted caramel, hazelnut cream, almond butter, eggnog (seasonal)
*optional add-ins and 2 flavor combinations available for fudge*
Pies
Availability of some products depends on seasonal ingredients.
Fruit Pies
Apple
Caramel apple
Apple butter (fall)
Dutch apple
Apple custard
Shaker lemon
Lemon meringue
Honey lemon meringue
Strawberry
Strawberry chamomile
Strawberry rhubarb (spring)
Strawberry balsamic
Mango honey (summer)
Apricot
Apricot vanilla
Pear
Ginger pear
Pear apple hazelnut
Pear nutmeg
Blueberry
Blueberry nectarine
Blueberry lavender
Blueberry custard
Blueberry crisp
Plum
Cinnamon plum
Fig plum
Peach
Bourbon peach
Peach bellini
Raspberry
Raspberry rose
Razapple
Shaker orange
Orange meringue
Lime meringue
Blackberry
Blackberry clove
Blackberry custard
Mixed berry
Cherry
Cherry almond
Mulled cherry
Cream Pies
Chocolate cream
Vanilla crumble cream
Banana cream
Coconut cream
Raspberry cream
Strawberry cream
Peach cream
Lemon cream
Pineapple cream
Sugar cream
Matcha cream (spring)
Maple cream
Chai cream
Caramel cream
Eggnog cream (winter)
Key lime
Whipped pumpkin cheesecake (fall)
Butterscotch meringue
Buttermilk
Buttermilk berry
Peppermint (winter)
Almond butter
Nutella
Cookie butter
White chocolate
Blueberry angel
Ricotta
Ribbon pudding
Other Pies
Shoofly
Pecan
Chess
Red velvet chess
Mississippi mud
Pumpkin
Pumpkin chocolate chai
Sweet potato
Orange streusel sweet potato
Salted honey
Sugar cookie
Chocolate chip
Oatmeal
The Kitchen Witches 